Yahya 
A new agreement between the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and international accounting firm Prager Metis stands out as a significant development in light of recent financial regulations and audit failures in the cryptocurrency world. Notably, the violations found in audits conducted before FTX’s collapse have brought attention to both the vulnerabilities in the cryptocurrency markets and the responsibilities of auditing firms. Prager Metis has agreed to pay $745,000 to resolve the charges brought by the SEC. However, this agreement is not limited to FTX audits; it also involves allegations that the firm violated independence rules while auditing over 200 companies between 2017 and 2020.
Audit Failures in the Collapse of FTX
Despite being a rapidly growing cryptocurrency exchange, FTX had an extremely fragile structure due to internal complexities and audit deficiencies. The lack of due diligence by Prager Metis while auditing this exchange has drawn serious criticism from the SEC. According to the SEC, the firm formed a team lacking sufficient experience when accepting FTX as an audit client. More critically, the firm’s failure to fully understand the complex relationship between FTX and its sister company, Alameda Research, as well as the vital role this relationship played in FTX’s business model, has been deemed a major issue.
Compliance Issues with Generally Accepted Auditing Standards (GAAS)
In the audit reports prepared by Prager Metis for FTX in 2021 and 2022, the firm claimed that the transactions complied with Generally Accepted Auditing Standards (GAAS). However, the SEC identified multiple areas where these reports did not meet the standards. GAAS serves as a fundamental auditing standard ensuring that firms independently, impartially, and accurately audit their clients’ financial reports. The inability of Prager Metis to recognize many risk factors that led to FTX’s collapse indicates a failure to properly apply these standards.
Penalties and Responsibilities for Prager Metis
Beyond the $745,000 payment, the agreement with the SEC includes significant financial and structural obligations. The firm has been held accountable for violations of independence rules in other audits outside of FTX. Due to violations in auditing over 200 companies between 2017 and 2020, Prager Metis has accepted a fine of $1.2 million and pre-judgment interest payments. This situation points to not only an audit failure but also a widespread issue within auditing policies.
Independent Consulting and Quality Control Measures
Under this agreement, Prager Metis will not only face financial penalties but also be required to implement fundamental changes in its audit and quality control processes. In line with SEC requests, the firm will work with an independent consultant to review its audit and quality control policies. This consulting process will enable the firm to restructure its auditing standards and prevent similar errors in the future. Additionally, restrictions have been placed on accepting new audit clients.
Trust Issues in the Cryptocurrency World
The collapse of FTX signifies a broader trust issue within the cryptocurrency world. The inherently decentralized nature of crypto markets, compounded by a lack of regulation, raises concerns among many investors and regulatory bodies. The fact that even audits of a major platform like FTX were not conducted with due diligence reveals the inadequacy of auditing and security standards across the sector. In this context, the SEC’s efforts to hold auditing firms like Prager Metis accountable signal that stricter regulations and audits will be implemented in cryptocurrency markets in the future.
This agreement between Prager Metis and the SEC contains significant lessons for both accounting firms and the cryptocurrency world. It highlights the need for auditing firms to operate with greater caution and diligence in a complex and rapidly evolving market like cryptocurrency. Furthermore, this agreement demonstrates that the lack of regulation in crypto markets poses serious risks not only for companies but also for auditing firms. The collapse of FTX and Prager Metis’s mistakes in these audits underscore the necessity for a more robust audit and regulatory framework moving forward.
You can also freely share your thoughts and comments about the topic in the comment section. Additionally, don’t forget to follow us on our Telegram, YouTube, and Twitter channels for the latest news and updates.